Blood Orange Old Fashioned

Thumbnail

Revitalize Your Taste Buds with a Vibrant Blood Orange Old Fashioned Cocktail

Image

There are cocktails, and then there are classics that tantalize your senses and revive your spirits. Enter the Blood Orange Old Fashioned—an inspired twist on a beloved bar staple that is perfect for those warmer evenings or when you're looking to elevate your cocktail game. The beauty of this concoction lies in its seamless marriage of sweet, bitter, and bold flavors, with a refreshing citrusy twist that invigorates each sip.

To master this cocktail, the key is in carefully balancing each ingredient. Begin with choosing plump, ripe orange slices, as they deliver a juicy sweetness that blends brilliantly with the bitters. The maraschino cherry is more than just a garnish; it adds a touch of sweetness and an eye-catching hue. The sparkling kick from the blood orange soda brings vibrance to each sip, standing out against the robust character of rye whiskey.

Preparation is simple but crucial—muddling the ingredients releases essential oils and flavors, so their choice and quality matter. Choose your tools wisely: a sturdy muddler, a classic Old Fashioned glass, and trust your instincts on using the right amount of ice to ensure your drink is chilled but not overly diluted.

Ingredients

  • Orange Slice: Choose a fresh, vibrant slice to impart natural juice and zest.
  • Dash of Orange Bitters: Essential for adding that unique citrus twist, maintaining balance.
  • 1 oz Blood Orange Soda: Provides a fizz that refreshes and complements the whiskey.
  • 1 Maraschino Cherry: Adds sweetness and visual appeal.
  • 2 oz Rye Whiskey: Opt for a quality brand to ensure a smooth and robust flavor.
Image

Step-by-Step Instructions

  1. Muddle: In an Old Fashioned glass, gently muddle an orange slice with a dash of orange bitters, a splash of blood orange soda, and a maraschino cherry. This releases the oils and juices, creating an aromatic base.
  2. Add Whiskey: Pour in the rye whiskey, letting it mingle with the muddled base.
  3. Ice It: Add ice cubes to the mixture. Stir gently but thoroughly, ensuring the drink is evenly chilled.
  4. Adjust Sweetness: For a sweeter profile, you can incorporate a teaspoon of superfine sugar during the muddling stage, or opt for honey whiskey instead of rye.
Image

Troubleshooting Tips

  • Too Bitter? Consider adding a splash more blood orange soda to mellow the bitterness.
  • Too Strong? Incorporate additional ice cubes and stir to slightly dilute.
  • Flavor Imbalance? A wedge of orange as garnish can help integrate the flavors vividly.
  • Lacking Sweetness? A dash of simple syrup or maple syrup can adjust sweetness effectively without overpowering.

Ideas for Pairing with the Recipe

  • Side Dishes: Pair this cocktail with festive finger foods like cheese platters, bruschetta, or sliders for a savory balance.
  • Drinks: Mix with sparkling water on the side for a refreshing cleanse between sips.
  • Desserts or Garnishes: Serve alongside citrus-based desserts such as lemon tarts or orange souffle to harmonize flavors.

How to Store Properly

  • For Refrigeration: Store any premixed components separately in airtight containers for up to 2 days. Re-mix before serving.
  • For Freezing: The cocktail is best enjoyed fresh, but you can freeze the muddled base in ice cube trays for a ready-to-mix version later.

FAQs

  • Can I use another type of whiskey? Absolutely! Bourbon makes a great substitution, offering a classic old-fashioned vibe.
  • Is there a non-alcoholic version possible? Simply replace the whiskey with a robust ginger ale for a delightful mocktail.
  • What if I don't have blood orange soda? Substitute with regular club soda and a splash of orange juice as an alternative.
  • How do I get the perfect muddling technique? Use a gentle twist motion with firm, even pressure to avoid over-crushing.
See all recipes
Get Ingredients

Easy recipes, delicious results

Subscribe to receive weekly news and the latest recipes

The quickest kitchen 2025. All rights reserved